Before you begin searching for reviews, it’s helpful to have an idea of when a play was first performed and if you want reviews of only recent performances or older performances. Years of coverage are included in the descriptions of each tool listed below.
American Drama Criticism
Coverage: 1890-1977, 1987-1990 (Supplement III), 1990-1993 (Supplement IV)
Location: Ref PS 332 .E33 1979a
Indexes reviews as well as criticism of American plays.
Allows you to search across many library databases simultaneously (including the Library Catalog). To find theater reviews, perform a keyword search for the title of a play and the phrase theater reviews, e.g. “heidi chronicles” and theater reviews
Guide to Critical Reviews
Part I: American Drama, 1909-1982
Part II: The Musical, 1909-1989
Part III: Foreign Drama, 1909-1977
Location: Ref PN2266 .S35
Index of theater reviews from American and Canadian magazines and the New York Times.
Location: Ref PN2596 .L6 W37
Daily listing of plays on the London stage. Entries include references to reviews.
New York Theatre Critics’ Reviews
Coverage: 1940-50, 1952-53, 1986-94 (Ask at Desk for issues prior to 1986).
Location: Skillman 808.2 .N53
Reprints of reviews from a variety of publications, including New York daily newspapers, Variety, and The Village Voice. Each volume contains a year-end index.
New York Times Directory of the Theater
Location: Ref PN2277 .N5 N49 1973x
Index of New York Times theater reviews. For reviews before 1920 and from 1970-2014, use the New York Times backfile.
Readers’ Guide Retrospective
Index of popular U.S. magazines. Headings for theater reviews vary. Try “drama,” “theater,” or the last name of a playwright.
Selected Theatre Criticism
Location: Ref PN2277 .N5 S44 1985
Reprints reviews of plays presented on the New York stage.
World Shakespeare Bibliography
Searchable bibliography with annotated entries for books, articles, reviews, and other materials related to Shakespeare.
To find reviews of Shakespearean plays, select the “Browse” option, click on the “+” before the title of the play you are interested in to reveal subheadings, and then click on the “?” next to the subheading “Stage productions.” Select a production from the resulting list. If the production was reviewed, a reference to the review(s) will be provided in the resulting information.